EXPERT INSIGHTS: How to Read and Understand Patent Documents

A Guide for Inventors

Profile Photo

Andrew Stentiford

Patent Attorney at Lightbringer

 

A patent document (either a patent application or a granted patent) is often seen as a complicated document which is actually difficult to understand. But as an inventor it's often important to try to work out what a patent is describing. This might be because you want to understand what a competitor is doing, or because a patent attorney has asked you for your comments. Therefore this post aims to help an inventor understand how to interpret a patent document.

Andrew Stentiford, Patent Attorney & Founding Member of Lightbringer.

 

Anatomy of a Patent

Every patent document has a standard structure. The first page of a patent document has bibliographical data. This includes details like the applicant, the inventors, key dates and a brief summary of its contents.

The detailed contents has four main parts - an abstract, description, claims and drawings. The description, claims and drawings together form the basis of the legal protection that the patent provides.
 

Claims: Why They Matter Most

The claims are numbered paragraphs towards the end of the patent document. Normally they are headed with the title "Claims". Within the claims there are two different types of claims. Independent claims and dependent claims. As an inventor you should focus your energy on understanding the claims and particularly the independent claim. This is because the independent claim sets out the scope of the invention, in its broadest sense.

In other words, the claims define what is protected by the granted patent in a legal sense. The claims determine precisely what proprietary technology can and cannot be controlled. Essentially, the claims set out all the features that are needed for the invention contained in the patent document. The dependent claims, which often refer to previous claims in the claim set, are within the scope of the independent claim. If you think of an independent claim as a Venn diagram, all the dependent claims referring to the independent claim will be within the circle of the independent claim. You can think of dependent claims as fallback positions, if the independent claim is not allowable.
 

Description: Where to Find the Specific Technical Detail

The detailed description then sets out how the invention described in the claims is put into effect. In other words, how would you as an engineer replicate this invention as described in the patent document?

The patent description will make reference to different features with reference numbers. The reference numbers are useful because often they are also in the claims, but also in the drawings. This can help understanding the concept in the patent document.

Not everything will be described in the patent document. Normally a patent document will assume some prior knowledge of the reader. The detailed description and drawings are a good place to start when you need to work out if a patent document is relevant to your invention.

 

Drawings: a Visual Aid

Use the drawings as a guide to interpret the document. This will help comprehend what is going on. Not all patent documents will have drawings, but many do.

 

Key Takeaway

One thing to consider about a patent document is that a patent document serves two purposes. It is a technical document that is describing an engineering concept but it is also a legal document defining legal protection for the patent owner.

This means sometimes the language in a patent document can be unclear from a purely engineering perspective. This is because a patent attorney may have selected words which are not necessarily normal in an engineering field. A patent attorney may want to try and cover different variants of an invention without limiting to a particular variant (e.g. using “controller” rather than “ECU” or “VCU”).

If you think a term in the claims is not clear, look to the description to help explain the term. This might help understanding.

It is important that an inventor can recognise their invention from the text of a patent document. The patent document should be clear to the inventor because the inventor knows their invention best. Lightbringer uses AI technology to draft clear patent applications which are still fit for purpose. Besides, if the inventor cannot understand the patent text, this means it is likely that others reading the patent text will also be confused!


Profile Photo

ANDREW STENTIFORD

Patent Attorney and Founding Member of Lightbringer

 

You may ALSO like these posts

Andrew Stentiford

Founding Member of Lightbringer

• Specialises in European and UK patents, trade marks, and design law.

• European & UK Patent Attorney & Trade Mark Attorney with over 20 years’ experience in IP.

• Partner at Invent Horizon IP patent consultancy

• Previous experience includes Head of Intellectual Property at Maersk Line & A.P. Møller Mærsk, Denmark where he built an IP department and an IP strategy across 5 different business units.

• In-house counsel at Stanley Black & Decker, Inc., UK, where he managed sizeable patent (+600) and trade mark portfolios (+1200) and handled many contentious matters including European litigation, patent oppositions, and trade mark oppositions.

• Educational background includes a MSci in Physics and Astronomy from Durham University, UK.

Previous
Previous

EXPERT INSIGHTS: How to Understand Feedback from the Patent Office

Next
Next

EXPERT INSIGHTS: The Patent You Dread Your Competitors Will File